Right from the moment I saw the different uniforms, I knew I was dealing with the early days of the show. However, I’d heard about Captain Pike in the original pilot, so I was a bit confused. Apparently this episode was shot as a second pilot.
As per usual, I made some notes as I watched it:
- In addition to the uniforms, Spock’s eyebrows and mannerisms immediately jumped out at me; as the episode continued, I realized that the writers softened his character significantly as the series progressed.
- The silent opening was a shock! I figured Shatner’s voice-over proceeded every Star Trek episode. It actually reminded me of Voyageur’s opening, which I’d never really liked; I’ll probably see it in a new light now (I’m planning to get all the Voyageur seasons shortly and give it another go).
- There seemed to be fewer women on the set, and they were all wearing pants; big difference. :-)
- The bridge seemed to be taller and narrower, or at least a bit more confined; I put it down to more black surrounding the monitors along the walls.
- Very few of the cast were familiar, save Kirk, Spock, Scotty and Sulu; (more on Sulu in a moment.)
- Having a psychiatrist on-board was new. The Next Generation really went for this with Troi and the Betazoids in general.
- Legitimizing extra-sensory perception (ESP) piqued my interest. I was hoping for more details on how they arrived at those scores. :-)
- I really enjoy little details like the new time estimates Kirk hints at, were they to remain on impulse power (i.e., years versus days to the nearest star base).
- That initial conversation in the sickbay between Kirk and Mitchell was absolutely fantastic: the perfect mix of familiarity and awkwardness (particularly on the part of Kirk).
- Mitchell’s staring at the camera as we watch from Kirk’s perspective on the bridge was really creepy. Gary Lockwood was great in the role, actually: such superb use of silence and subtle expressions.
- I found it odd that Mitchell’s drop in vitals didn’t raise any alarm from the instruments; it was eerie!
- Sulu’s the math guy? Strange. I actually thought he made a mistake by referring to Mitchell’s potential progression as geometric; turns out I’m the one who’s been out of school too long. :-)
- The greying of Mitchell’s hair was a nice touch.