I was really surprised to see the story credited to Richard Matheson. I got my hands on a copy of I Am Legend recently, and am looking forward to reading it.
As per usual, I jotted down some thoughts as I was watching this episode (for the first time, I might add):
- Note: I haven’t seen many episodes from the first season to date.
- The introduction was superb: what a way to end it, with that eerie lighting under the Kirk close-up.
- The freehand camera work and the horns in the score during Kirk’s brandy rampage really left me feeling off-balance; I didn’t know what he was going to do. :-)
- Spock’s insistence that the truth be kept from the crew was very emotional, almost human; it was really jarring for me, coming off the entire second season — I’ll have more to say on this in a moment.
- The alternate Kirk’s outburst in his quarters was fantastic — I had chills running up my spine!
- The confrontation in the bowels of the ship was well choreographed: the doubles weren’t too obvious; that goes for the rest of the episode too — some really great work in the sickbay, actually.
- Spock’s analysis of the situation was typical, if a little emotional (for him), but his justification for a possibly perceived lack of empathy — “That’s the way I am” — was a bit odd; I guess it depends on when this episode aired: how much do we know about Vulcans (and half Vulcans) at this point?
- Re the predicament with Sulu’s team: again, a perfect use for shuttlecraft. I should read up on how they were introduced to the show, and whether it was consist with episodes like this one.
- Spock’s diving in to take over a conversation with Sulu was excellent; Kirk’s slow deterioration in general was superb; you felt the discomfort of those in the know, as they attempted to assess Kirk’s mental state from moment to moment.
- The final debate between Spock and McCoy was brilliant: both sides argued well, and Kirk’s indecision was positively painful to watch! :-)
- Again, however, as a final point: Spock was unusually forceful in that debate (I liked it, don’t get me wrong!); and he described his Vulcan ancestry as “alien”: that’s different, isn’t it? And so was his final comment to the Yeoman, come to think of it; a bit creepy, frankly, seein’ as she was assaulted (ah, the 60s ;-) ).
